Tuesday, September 4, 2018

Brothers Arrested for Grand Theft

James Goins

Matthew Goins

September 4, 2018

Levy County deputies responded to 11421 NW 112 Place, the Springside Retirement Community, on August 20, 2018 to a report of the theft of an enclosed trailer. The complainant, a friend of the owner, discovered the trailer missing and reported the theft in the absence of the owner. The complainant was able to provide deputies with the owner’s information who when contacted, gave a description of what was inside the trailer. The owner told deputies he stored two kayaks, a mower and recumbent bicycles and other tools in the trailer which had a combined value of over $5,000.00.

Investigators discovered two kayaks matching the description of the stolen ones had been pawned at a local pawn shop in Gainesville. Investigators were able to confirm these were the stolen kayaks and learned James Goins (2-25-86) of Chiefland had pawned them.  

Additional investigation revealed witnesses who observed the trailer parked at Goins’ home testified to seeing Samantha Gath riding a lawn mower matching the stolen mower description. Investigators learned Gath was in custody in Dixie County on unrelated charges and interviewed her there. She identified her boyfriend, James Goins and his brother Matthew Goins (3-10-91), as participating in the theft of the trailer. She provided information on where other stolen items could be located.

Investigators located both James and Matthew Goins and placed them under arrest for grand theft. Both James and Matthew cooperated with investigators and additional stolen property was recovered. 

James Goins is being held at the Levy County Detention Facility. His bond was set at $20,000 for the grand theft and he has been additionally charged with violation of probation. Matthew Goins is being held on a $20,000 bond. Charges on Gath are pending. Additional charges are expected to be filed in both Alachua and Gilchrist counties as a result of this investigation.